Best Pizza in Clermont
Enjoy Timeless Italian Pastas & NY-Style Pizzas in a Beautiful SettingTry our most popular items
Treat yourself to our must-try list that has everyone talking
🍕 Craving a Slice?
🍕 Why I Love NY Pizza?
🍕 Join Us Today!
Order From Our Website
What our guests are saying
Check out our most recent reviews!
Incredible Lunch Special. $4.99 for 2 slices and fountain drink. Garlic Knots are wonderful. Server Gabby is the best and most attentive waitress I've probably had anywhere in at least 6 months. Will be writing an in depth review on my Pizza Chap Pizza Blog.

Darrin V.
We love I Love NY Pizza! The lunch specials are a great price and even available on weekends! The owner is very friendly and nice as well. We have never had a bad experience here.

Candy B.
This was our first time trying this pizza place and we were not disappointed at all! The pizza was the best we've had in a long time and we've tried many local places! And they have an IPA which isn't usually the case :) Our server was amazing as well - we did not get her name but she was so friendly and very attentive! Needless to say we will be going back!

Aron M.
A Glimpse into Greatness
See for yourself why our pizza is a local favorite—browse the photos and get a taste of what everyone’s raving about!
Featuring
Gluten-Free Options
Healthy Options
Easy Parking
Vegan Options
I Love NY Pizza Rewards
Frequently asked questions
We are known for Garlic Bread, Mozzarella Sticks, Caesar Salad, and Garlic Knots
We are located in Clermont, FL at 532 Cagan Park Ave
We serve the following areas: Horizon West, Bay Lake, Reunion, Celebration, Lake Buena Vista, Eva, Loughman, Orange Mountain.